
A highlight at the New York Film Festival, Jesse Eisenberg’s latest film, THE DEBUT, pays homage to community theater as the nurturing home of many a Broadway musical. THE DEBUT stars one bona fide Broadway legend—that is, Bernadette Peters—who plays a “legend” who “does not age” named Serena Cherry. She would be the “super,” Miss Danielle, in the fictive musical “Nosy Neighbors” about an average, everyday apartment building. When Serena quits because the role is too small, the part falls to Mona Friedman, a mousy, homemaker with little going on in her suburban life. A mother to entitled teens, a wife to a man who ignores her, she is not heard. Until now.
Hard to think of Julianne Moore as fading into the woodwork, but here, in her sweater sets and blown out coif, she’s no match for the colorful drama queens already cast by director Jerry, the formidable Paul Giamatti.
Eisenberg wrote “Mona” for Julienne Moore who insisted: she had to sing, she would not play a “mother,” (at least not a typical one), she would be silly. At the New York Film Festival Q&A, Moore called herself Jesse’s avatar. And as a person who is looking for her next moment, Mona goes from novice to good enough, not the mega talent of Bernadette Peters, or Halle Bailey who stars in the “Nosy Neighbors” meta-musical, but just enough to keep her dreams real. Veering off-script, Miss Danielle steals the show within the show.
As Paul Giamatti plays an Oz-like figure, the director of the musical at the smalltown Brooks theater, he lends the movie gravitas, a wistful desire to be center stage, a wisdom to guide his cast to opening night. Eisenberg soft shoes his acting chops as a tenant with a stopped toilet, and ceased personal plumbing—wink, wink. The credits roll as Sondheim’s “Broadway Baby” is heard. Otherwise, songs are credited to Eisenberg. He nails it in this, his third feature.
Why did everyone want to be in this movie? The script. The writing is so good, even Lin Manuel Miranda is paying attention, inviting Eisenberg to his home in Washington Heights. What might they be cooking up? He would not say at the premiere pre-party at Brasserie Boulud. You may see THE DEBUT as an homage to Woody Allen–cue BROADWAY DANNY ROSE—well, Jesse Eisenberg’s hush about that too.
























