Excuse a bit of fangirl glee at seeing Alden Ehrenreich and Patrick Ball in “Becky Shaw,” each debuting on Broadway at the Helen Hayes Theater. Handsome guys, yes, they each play a form of misguided masculinity in this Gina Gionfriddo comedy.
The Becky Shaw script is a tour de force of bad behavior, enriched by stunning performances. Under Trip Cullman’s deft direction, the timing is brilliant for a perhaps familiar family scenario of mismanaged money after the death of a patriarch. As Ehrenreich’s Max, a kind of adopted son—it’s complicated—attempts to salvage the financial situation, he sleeps with the woman he grew up with Suzanna (Lauren Patten) in kind of an “ew” moment. Fast forwarding, she marries Ball’s Andrew, a dim but sweet writer she’s met on a ski vacation. Eh, she does not ski. Working at a job he does not like, Andrew wants to fix up an office temp, the titular Becky Shaw (Madeline Brewer) with Max. Needless to say, this is a bad idea.
Bookending the mismatches and icky male behavior all around is Linda Emond as Susan, the widow and uber-Mom here—who needs to downsize. That’s more than a real estate strategy.
With all the hilarious apparatus at play, including slamming doors as in a Feydeau farce, why is the play called Becky Shaw? The playwright said she was exploring the kinds of ideals we bring to relationships.
Dimple chinned Patrick Ball pops on screen in HBO’s “The Pit.” In this play he’s got a dumb rescue-the-damsel-in-distress code of chivalry—that makes him perfect for marrying Suzanna, an insecure psychology PHD. He commits to tending to Becky after a calamitous first date with Max. Tenacious, she keeps on going after him—even when, cad that he is, he ghosts her. She does not let go. If we met this woman in life, we’d be scared. Very scared. “You should be,” said Brewer at the afterparty.
A great night for theater, we were delighted to see many familiar faces: Cherry Jones, Mare Winningham, Anthony Edwards, and a handful from “The Pitt.” Tony Kushner gave notes to Emond. We ran into Joe Mantello, directing the upcoming “Death of a Salesman” revival starring Nathan Lane. Lane of course can do anything but it is still a stretch to imagine him as Willy Loman. “Just wait,” said Mantello. “He will surprise you.”
























